San Francisco judge dismisses lawsuit against Great Highway park

Judge Dismisses Lawsuit Against Proposition K

SAN FRANCISCO – A San Francisco Superior Court judge dismissed claims in a lawsuit against Proposition K. This ballot measure permanently cleared traffic from the Great Highway to create a two-mile park.

Response from Friends of Sunset Dunes

Friends of Sunset Dunes, an advocacy group, stated that the legal action affirmed Proposition K’s legal standing. They called the lawsuit against the park “wasteful.”

Background on Proposition K

Proposition K passed with over 54% of the vote in November 2024. However, the debate continued. Residents in the Sunset District recalled their supervisor after the vote. They argued that closing a major thoroughfare would flood their streets with traffic.

Victory for Friends of Sunset Dunes

Friends of Sunset Dunes celebrated the judge’s decision in the lawsuit, Boschetto vs the City and County of San Francisco, as a victory. They stated, “This ruling affirms Proposition K’s legal foundation and the city’s authority to create a permanent coastal park.”

Volunteers and Opposition

The group mentioned that their volunteers are working to develop the coastal park. They criticized “anti-park zealots” for wasting public resources in their attempts to overturn the decision.

Comments from Lucas Lux

Lucas Lux, president of Friends of Sunset Dunes, invited opponents to accept the will of San Franciscans. He urged them to work together to enhance the coastal park.

Supervisor Alan Wong’s Position

Alan Wong, the Sunset District supervisor, reiterated his earlier stance. He expressed readiness to support a ballot initiative to reopen the Great Highway. This initiative would allow vehicles on weekdays and close the highway on weekends.

Wong’s Engagement with Constituents

Wong stated he has spoken with constituents across the political spectrum. He believes his values align with most residents and organizations in District 4.

Wong’s Previous Vote

When sworn in last month, Wong indicated he was open to revisiting the issue of reopening the Great Highway. He also noted he voted against Proposition K.

Recall of Joel Engardio

Last September, Joel Engardio was recalled as the Sunset District supervisor. His support for Sunset Dunes was a primary reason for his ouster. Other prominent politicians, including former Mayor London Breed and former House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, supported the park.

Engardio’s Statement

Engardio issued a statement after the judge dismissed all claims in the lawsuit against Proposition K. He said, “It’s time to consider Sunset Dunes settled. The park is good for the environment, local businesses, and the health of visitors.”

Future Outlook

Engardio believes future generations will view the controversy as silly. He stated, “The coast belongs to everyone, and it won’t be long before a majority will embrace Sunset Dunes.”